2015 Oscar Picks – The Big Six


It’s hard to believe it but tomorrow night is Oscar night. I realize that some dismiss the event, but I always enjoy it. Granted, I rarely agree with them, but I always love the opportunity to celebrate movies and talk about them among my movie loving pals. To be honest this year’s Oscars seem to be lacking the excitement mainly due to what could be termed a less than exciting field of nominees. Nevertheless there are some intriguing scenarios so I’m going to talk about them, namely the Big Six Oscar categories. Here are the nominees, who I think should win, who I think will win, the category’s most criminal omission, and a brief breakdown.


“American Sniper”
“The Grand Budapest Hotel”
“The Imitation Game”
“The Theory of Everything”

WHO SHOULD WIN – “Boyhood”

WHO WILL WIN – “Birdman”


BREAKDOWN – If you would have asked me a month ago I would have told you with certainty that “Boyhood” would win Best Picture. But over time there has been this weird swell of backlash and regardless of how unfair it paints the film, “Boyhood” seems to have taken a fairly big blow. And it just may be enough to knock it out of a Best Picture Oscar. But the more I thought about it the more it makes sense. Richard Linklater doesn’t make Oscar-type movies. He makes small intimate pictures so it makes sense that “Boyhood” would lose to the much showier “Birdman”. It’s not that “Birdman” is a bad film. It simply isn’t nearly as profound as it thinks it is while “Boyhood” will stick with me for years.


Wes Anderson – “The Grand Budapest Hotel”
Alejandro G. Iñárritu – “Birdman”
Richard Linklater – “Boyhood”
Bennett Miller – “Foxcatcher”
Morten Tyldum – “The Imitation Game”

WHO SHOULD WIN – Wes Anderson

WHO WILL WIN – Alejandro Iñárritu

MOST CRIMINAL OMISSION – Christopher Nolan (“Interstellar”)

BREAKDOWN – This is perhaps the most intriguing category of the night. Part of me would love to see Richard Linklater win for his remarkable and intensely personal achievement. But suddenly I find myself rooting for Wes Anderson. Much like Linklater, he doesn’t make films that normally attract Oscar votes outside of the screenplay categories. That’s a shame because “Budapest” is a movie that continues to grow on me. So this category belongs to Iñárritu. For some reason the visual side of directing seems to be what is often awarded these days, and the visual presentation was certainly the strong point of “Birdman”.


Steve Carrell – “Foxcatcher”
Bradley Cooper – “American Sniper”
Benedict Cumberbatch – “The Imitation Game”
Michael Keaton – “Birdman”
Eddie Redmayne – “The Theory of Everything”

WHO SHOULD WIN – Michael Keaton

WHO WILL WIN – Michael Keaton

MOST CRIMINAL OMISSION – Jake Gyllenhaal (“Nightcrawler”)

BREAKDOWN – This is another category that seems to have tightened up in the last few weeks. I have always loved Michael Keaton and it’s been great seeing him back on the big screen getting some significant roles. I’m definitely rooting for him and at one point he seemed like a slam dunk. But Eddie Redmayne seems to be gaining momentum and some people have him picked as their winner. I just can’t see him overcoming Keaton’s early established lead, and if Redmayne were to win it be a huge surprise.


Marion Cotillard – “Two Days, One Night”
Felicity Jones – “The Theory of Everything”
Julianne Moore – “Still Alice”
Rosamund Pike – “Gone Girl”
Reese Witherspoon – “Wild”

WHO SHOULD WIN – Marion Cotillard

WHO WILL WIN – Julianne Moore

MOST CRIMINAL OMISSION – Marion Cotillard (“The Immigrant”)

BREAKDOWN – This is one category that I can’t be completely objective about. I still haven’t seen “Still Alice”. But Marion Cotillard never ceases to amaze me. She is one of the most naturally gifted actresses I have ever seen and her work in “Two Days, One Night” is a shining example of her immense talent. I have no doubt that Moore does a great job, but I have a hard time believing anyone could beat what Cotillard gave us in two different 2014 performances.


Patricia Arquette – “Boyhood”
Laura Dern – “Wild”
Keira Knightley – “The Imitation Game”
Emma Stone – “Birdman”
Meryl Streep – “Into the Woods”

WHO SHOULD WIN – Patricia Arquette

WHO WILL WIN – Patricia Arquette

MOST CRIMINAL OMISSION – Agata Kulesza (“Ida”)

BREAKDOWN – Aside from Meryl Streep’s ridiculous nomination, this is a pretty intriguing list. It’s also another category that I think the Academy is going to get right. Arquette is such a pivotal ingredient to what made “Boyhood” so special. In many ways she is the film’s centerpiece. I always enjoy a little intrigue and suspense when it comes to awarding Oscars. This is one case where I’m glad there is no question and the winner is a sure thing.


Robert Duvall – “The Judge”
Ethan Hawke – “Boyhood”
Edward Norton – “Birdman”
Mark Ruffalo – “Foxcatcher”
J.K. Simmons – “Whiplash

WHO SHOULD WIN – Ethan Hawke

WHO WILL WIN – J.K. Simmons

MOST CRIMINAL OMISSION – Robert Pattinson (“The Rover”)

BREAKDOWN – The winner of this category is as certain as death and taxes. J.K. Simmons should have a place cleared off on his mantle because there is no way anyone else in this category has a shot at winning. Simmons is a guy everyone likes so it’s hard not to be happy for him. Personally I would love to see Hawke get the nod here. He is the perfect fit for his flaky but well-intentioned character in Boyhood and many of the film’s best scenes were the ones he was in.

So there you have my picks for who should win and who will win along with a few glaring omissions that I’m sure will shame the Academy to no end. So what do you think of my take on tomorrow night’s Oscars? Where did I get it wrong? Who do you have as the winners? Share your thoughts in the comments section below and we will see how we did on Monday.


21 thoughts on “2015 Oscar Picks – The Big Six

  1. Interesting! Some of our predictions differ in the big categories. I’m still going with Boyhood for Best Picture but it really seems like a toss up between that and Birdman. I could end up being wrong about a lot of the main ones.

    • I need to check yours out as well. I really think the acting categories are pretty locked but crazier things have happened. Occasionally the Academy does throw us some curve balls. It’ll be interesting to see if they do this year.

  2. Verrrry nice post Keith, and I really admire your acknowledgement of Mr. Pattinson for his work in ‘The Rover.’ I was spellbound by how much I liked him in that, given he could’ve easily made a list for my Least Favorite People of All Time from his work in Twilight. Lol!

    I don’t know if I’m going to watch them this year or not. Still undecided. The Academy has really pissed me off with their exclusion of The Lego Movie and their inclusion of Meryl Streep.

    • You mention two VERY good reasons to blow off this year’s Oscars. I’m still gonna watch but both of those things are enough to leave me grumbling.

      And amen about Pattinson. NEVER would I have EVER anticipated championing a performance of his. But he is sooo incredibly good in The Rover. He deserves recognition!!!

      • Yes, yes he does. 🙂

        Idk, I might tune in for awhile, as your point about it being another forum for all us film lovers to discuss the medium itself really hits home for me. It’s a uniting process. Even if the choices are sometimes head-scratching. 😀

      • Very head-scratching and rarely ever reflective of my favorites. But something about it always excites me. This year not as much, but I’m still game.

      • if ever there was gonna be a year i was gonna podcast throughout the event it’d be this one as I can afford to be a bit more distracted. but, I prob won’t. Too much effort! Lol. Same thing happened last year.

  3. Nice predictions Keith! I’ll be watching, still missed Alice, Whiplash, and The Grand Budapest Hotel but seen many of the rest. Still miffed at many of the exclusions but it is what it is at this point.

    • Omissions and snubs stand out every year, don’t they? For some reason these year stands out. For me The Lego Movie is utterly incomprehensible. No matter how hard I try I can’t find any justification for it.

  4. I think Wes Anderson should win, too. I suspect the trend will continue and most all of the films will get a golden statue. When was the last landslide? Return of the King? Why am I not excited about the Best Actress category?

    • I think you’re right. Return of the King was the last landslide. The last few years have seen different winners for director and picture. I expect that to continue this year.

    • The Best Actor category was ridiculously stacked this year, but the omissions of Gyllenhaal and Ralph Fiennes has soured me a tad.

      So are you thinking Boyhood will get the Best Picture win? If so I hope you’re right.

      • For me David Oyelowo’s snub hurt as well! Yeah in my opinion Birdman was good, but not great. But I like that you rooted for Wes Anderson, I preferred Moonrise Kingdom though!

  5. Ethan Hawke over JK Simmons? You kidding? Simmons blasts Whiplash with a ferocity I’ve not seen in film in years. Hawke was, and is, a hugely overrated dramatic actor (IMO, of course) whose only decent role was in Linklater’s “Before” trilogy. His work in Boyhood was above average, but not Oscar-cailber.

    That being said, I agree with you in almost every other aspect! Have fun watching, I know I will!

    • JK Simmons was big, loud, and ferocious. But let’s be honest, he was so over the top (intentionally so) that he was almost a cartoon character. Hawke was absolutely perfect for what his role needed. Big always gets the attention but it isn’t always the best. That’s my take on it at least. But hey, Hawke hasn’t a chance.

  6. Pingback: 2015 Oscars Rundown & Random Thoughts | Keith & the Movies

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s