
You can be certain that some will go into “The Electric State” with their knives already sharpened. Afterall, it’s a $320 million streaming blockbuster from Netflix which makes it an easy target. But this latest small screen creation (that would look amazing on the big screen) is nowhere near the trainwreck it has been tagged as. But it also doesn’t live up to its status as one of the most expensive movies ever made.
With “The Electric State”, the directing duo of Anthony and Joe Russo continue to find their post-Marvel footing, reteaming with frequent collaborators, screenwriters Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely. This time they’re adapting Simon Stålenhag’s dystopian sci-fi graphic novel of the same name after acquiring the rights back in 2017. They’ve brought this massive undertaking together with a hefty backing from Netflix who apparently handed the brothers a blank check.
From the very start you’ll notice “The Electric State” sports a star-studded ensemble providing both live-action performances and voicework. The featured talent includes Millie Bobby Brown, Chris Pratt, Ke Huy Quan, Stanley Tucci, Giancarlo Espositio, Woody Harrelson, Anthony Mackie, Colman Domingo, Jenny Slate, Brian Cox, Alan Tudyk, Woody Norman, and Jason Alexander among others. Just listing the names gives you a good sense of where a lot of the money went.

As for its storytelling, “The Electric State” struggles to find its own voice. So much of its story follows a familiar and well-traveled trajectory. We feel three steps ahead of it the entire way. There’s also no nuance in the handling of its themes. They’re mostly plastered on the surface rather than thoughtfully explored through the characters and their journeys. So that leaves the movie leaning heavily on its star power and impressive visuals.
Its 90’s set story takes place in the aftermath of a war between humans and robots. We learn humans had made robots the backbone of the world’s workforce, shaping them to do whatever labor mankind desired. Eventually the robots, led by the noble Mr. Peanut (voiced by Harrelson), began pushing for freedom and equality. But a paranoid humanity resisted which led to a global war.
After much fighting, the humans finally gained the upper-hand with the invention of the neurocaster by a wealthy CEO, Ethan Skate (Tucci). While the technology empowered mankind to win the war, Slate turned it into a virtual reality network that connected the entire world. Soon humans became obsessed with neurocasters, losing themselves in the VR worlds it created. Meanwhile robots have been banished, either disassembled or sent off to the reservation styled Exclusion Zone.
It’s within this world that we meet Michelle (Brown), a ward of the state ever since she lost her parents and was separated from her brilliant but anxious kid brother, Christopher (Woody Norman). Late one evening Michelle is shocked when a small robot in the form of Christopher’s favorite cartoon character, Kid Cosmo (voiced by Alan Tudyk) sneaks into her room. Within the robot is a part of her brother’s consciousness (at least I think) who tells Michelle he desperately needs her help.

So Michelle sets out for the west coast to find, rescue, and reunite with her brother, guided by an illegal robot who draws all kinds of unwanted attention. But she finds help in an unexpected place – a smuggler named Keats (Chris Pratt in a hideously bad mop) and his robot sidekick, Herman (voiced by Anthony Mackie). They agree to escort Michelle and her Cosmo-bot across the war-torn wasteland of the Midwest towards Seattle. But of course there are plenty of dangers along the way from rogue robots to Ethan Skate, the nefarious CEO who we quickly learn is the movie’s big baddie.
To its credit, “The Electric State” looks amazing thanks in large part to cinematography Stephen F. Windon and the VFX team led by supervisor Matthew Butler. There is an incredible amount of detail put into the world from the retrofuturistic cities to the rust and grime of old battlefields. There are also tons of cool and amusing robot designs. Similarly, the action scenes are well choreographed and shot, incorporating both style and humor into the sequences.
If only the story had more weight. If only it made us feel something for the characters. If only it made the stakes seem as high as we’re told they are. If only its themes of tech dependency, family, and human connection were more seriously treated. Instead we’re left with stunning visuals, a slew of needle drops, and a great cast (some of whom are woefully underused). That was enough to hold my attention and keep me mildly entertained. But it also left me frustrated. The Russos have created a fascinating world that feels like it’s still waiting to be discovered. And no matter how hard I tried, I never felt a connection to it.
VERDICT – 2.5 STARS

The cast and the premise sound promising. I only read the first half until after I can watch it … tomorrow, yes! Sorry to see the 2.5 stars. More proof that throwing $$ at something means automatic success 😦
It’s a movie that has its moments. And it’s certainly not as horrid as many fellow critics make it out to be. But it’s not especially good either. It’s very fair mainly because the story just doesn’t do much at all.
I’ve put off watching it so far, probably will at some point just for the visuals.
It’s not a terrible watch. And there are moments of fun. And I would say see it for the world itself. Just keep your expectations in check.
I never have great expectations from movies much anymore.
I still do, but I can certainly understand why people wouldn’t.
Thanks for another great review. No criticism of the film, but I believe there’s no point spending this much money on a film for streaming at home. At least have a proper cinema release first! “Blank cheque” Have Netflix found their own quantitive easing or money laundering systems or both? 😂 😝
Thanks so much Paul. It really is hard to imagine a $320 million budget for a movie streaming at home. I get that things are changing, but that kind of money blows my mind.
So this is what $320 million is wasted on… I think maybe the reason the Russos were so successful with the films for the MCU is because of Kevin Feige overseeing the production. Having these 2 return to the fold might not be a good idea. This looks like fucking shit. A bunch of smaller indie and art films would be a better use of $320 million. Not shit like this.
Actually, the money put into the visuals and the cast is well spent. But $320 million should buy you a better story than this.
It just shows you a robot and says that it’s a boy who is connected to a computer. then total shit. seriously.
Nothing about either the premise or your write up makes me want to see it. A heck of a cast though.
It’s as middle of the road as you can get. Some fun stuff here and there and some terrific visuals. But that’s about it.
First I thought: this is a movie for kids.
Sorry, I’m continuing my comme, I decided to give it a try last Saturday, and the movie was pretty entertaining. As you said, it has its moments. Not too bad, considering the amount of money spent on it.
Exactly. I’m not sure that I will ever watch again, but I got enough enjoyment out of it. Not at all a hard movie to sit through.