
I personally enjoy Christmas movies. Old ones, new ones, serious ones, silly ones – there is a wide variety that my family and I watch each year. But they only really resonate with me during the Christmas season. For me that starts in earnest on the day after Thanksgiving. So watching and reviewing a new Christmas movie outside of those silly self-imposed parameters is a risky prospect.
But a big tip of the toboggan to “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever”, a genuinely funny and uplifting holiday dramedy from director Dallas Jenkins. Written for the screen by the trio of Ryan Swanson, Platte Clark, and Darin McDaniel, this big-hearted family-friendly feature is an adaptation of Barbara Robinson’s beloved 1972 children’s novel of the same name. And what can I say – it has all the makings of a new perennial Christmastime favorite.

“The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” uses a similar framework as the beloved yuletide classic “A Christmas Story”. It features a narrator sharing a meaningful story from their childhood. But instead of the bespectacled Ralphie, here it’s young Beth Bradley (Molly Belle Wright) who lives with her mother Grace (a terrific Judy Greer), her dad Bob (Pete Holmes), and her kid brother Charlie (Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez) in the cozy little town of Emmanuel.
Emmanuel is perhaps best known for two things: their annual Christmas pageant which is about to celebrate its 75th anniversary, and the Herdman kids – unruly terrors from the proverbial other side of the tracks who are known to lie, fight, bully, cuss, steal, and occasionally set a fire or two around town. Needless to say, everybody in Emmanuel knows the six rowdy Herdmans – Ralph, Leroy, Claude, Ollie, Gladys, and their tough-as-leather leader Imogene.
Everyone is anticipating this year’s pageant to be the biggest one ever. But things take a turn after its long-time organizer and director, the stern Mrs. Armstrong (Mariam Bernstein) takes a spill and breaks both her legs. With no one stepping up to take the reins, Grace volunteers to head this year’s pageant. It’s a noble undertaking that proves to be more challenging than she ever expected.
As Grace holds her first casting meeting at the local church, she’s shocked by the sudden appearance of the Herdmans who stake their claims on the Nativity’s biggest roles while daring any of the other kids to try out. The rough and gruff Imogene is expressly intent on playing Mary which raises the ire of several other parents. So Grace finds herself in a pickle. Does she let the unchurched Herdmans participate and risk ruining the biggest Christmas pageant in its 75-year history? Or does she take the safe route and replace them, losing the true meaning of the season in the process?

It’s not too hard to figure out where things go, especially considering movies like this tend to follow similar paths. And you’ll spot several well-worn Christmas tropes scattered around. Yet “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” maintains an irresistible charm and a heartfelt sincerity that never turns saccharine. It’s also consistently funny and surprisingly self-aware. And while it clearly has something to say, it doesn’t beat anyone over the head. Instead, its message flows naturally throughout the story, from its playful opening to its affecting finish.
“The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” turns out to be a bona fide delight that’s sure to warm the heart of the jolliest elf or the most hardened Grinch. A perfectly tuned Judy Greer is a treat while Beatrice Schneider as Imogene is a revelation. They’re joined by a fun and festive ensemble who help make this holiday feature one of the most joyous surprises of 2024. “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” is in theaters now.
VERDICT – 4 STARS


















