
It goes without saying, but few have had better big screen careers than the legendary Clint Eastwood. In addition to appearing in over 60 movies, the 94-year-old cinema icon has directed and/or produced a total of 44 features. He has even composed a total of seven film scores. On top of all that, he has received eleven Academy Award nominations and has had four Oscar night wins.
And that brings us to “Juror #2”, a feature that many are reporting could be the final film in Eastwood’s brilliant seven decade-long career. Eastwood himself hasn’t personally said anything about retiring, But if he does choose to step away, it’s hard to imagine a better movie for the legend’s potential swan song. Now if only it could get the big screen rollout it deserves.
“Juror #2” is every bit a gripping courtroom drama. But it resonates most as a thought-provoking morality play that uses the American legal system as a conduit for its incisive study of guilt and justice. The film is strengthened by its propulsive and character-focused script from Jonathan Abrams and a strikingly nuanced lead performance from Nicholas Hoult who continues his phenomenal career-defining year. But it’s Eastwood’s signature tight and efficient storytelling that makes the movie hit on all cylinders.

In “Juror #2” Eastwood taps into his career-long fascination with moral quandaries within modern social constructs. Here he wastes no time getting started by introducing us to Justin Kemp (Hoult), a journalist living in Savannah, Georgia with his wife Ally (Zoey Deutch). The two are nervously navigating the third trimester of Ally’s high-risk pregnancy when Justin receives a summons to report for jury duty. His hopes are that the pregnancy will be reason enough for him to be relieved. No such luck.
Justin is on the jury for a local murder case involving the death of a young woman named Kendall Carter (Francesca Eastwood). Her body was discovered near a bridge in a rocky creek bed. The accused killer is her boyfriend, James Michael Sythe (Gabriel Basso). The case is being prosecuted by Assistant District Attorney Faith Killebrew (Toni Collette) who is on the home stretch of her campaign to succeed her boss as the new DA. Faith believes she has all she needs to convict Sythe including eyewitness testimony, the medical examiner’s opinion, and Sythe’s own violent history.
But Sythe’s attorney, public defender Eric Resnick (Chris Messina), believes there is ample reason for reasonable doubt. Aside from the defendant passionately proclaiming his innocence, there is no murder weapon. And the defense contends that the eyewitness accounts don’t hold up under scrutiny. This sets up and fuels the two sides of the courtroom segment of Eastwood’s story.
But the big twist lies with Justin. As he listens to the prosecution and defense plea their cases he realizes he may have an unexpected connection to the murder. Justin’s sudden moral dilemma spills over into the deliberations as he becomes Sythe’s most ardent defender out of the twelve jurors. The tension steadily ratchets up as Eastwood and Abrams drip-feeds us more and more information. Over time the revelations help paint a clearer picture, yet there’s enough vagueness to keep things suspenseful.

There’s so much to admire about Eastwood’s sure-handed direction. It’s seen in his approach to the story that brings to mind such classics as Kurosawa’s “Rashomon” and Lumet’s “12 Angry Men”. We see it in how he opens up his themes with scalpel-sharp precision. And it shows in his confident use of Yves Bélanger’s sturdy classical cinematography.
But it’s perhaps clearest seen in Eastwood’s handling of his actors. Not only does the cast get good material, they also get space to explore and create. Hoult is especially good, conveying the weight of guilt in the light of uncertainty. Collette is outstanding in a role she takes in some unexpected directions. J. K. Simmons is his normal rock-solid self playing a skeptical juror with a unique insight. And Kiefer Sutherland gets a small but welcomed part as Justin’s mentor.
“Juror #2” hinges on a twist that could have easily turned into a cheap gimmick. But Clint Eastwood is not the kind of filmmaker to allow that to happen. His film has a lot more meat on its bones. Its themes are potent, the stakes get higher, and actions have far-reaching consequences. At the same time it entertains like an old-fashioned, well-oiled genre film. If this is Eastwood’s final film (and the selfish side of me really hopes it isn’t), what a way to wrap a truly remarkable career.
VERDICT – 4.5 STARS




















