
In “Killer Whale”, director Jo-Anne Brechin attempts to add a slightly new spin to the sharksploitation genre by making an orca the chief antagonist. Unfortunately that’s not enough to save the movie from the sea of well-worn tropes and its obvious budget constraints. The latter issue grows especially burdensome, specifically in the second half where the glaringly obvious digital effects distract from the experience more than enhances it.
Co-written by Brechin and Katharine McPhee, “Killer Whale” follows best friends Maddie (Virginia Gardner) and Trish (Mel Jarnson), who reunite after a tragedy tore Maddie’s world apart. Only a year earlier, Maddie lost her prospective boyfriend Chad (Isaac Crawley) and most of her hearing during a robbery at a burger restaurant where she worked. Since then she has mostly disconnected from the things she loves, including Trish.

But Trish pays Maddie a visit, insisting that her grieving friend joins her on a seven-day, all expenses paid trip to the Andaman Sea Islands in Thailand. Maddie reluctantly agrees and the two take off, settling in at a swanky beachfront resort. During a night of drinking and dancing, the two meet a local bartender named Josh (Mitchell Hope). The next morning Josh sweeps Maddie and Trish away for an afternoon of fun at a remote lagoon. But their fun turns to terror after they’re attacked by an enormous killer whale.
We learn the angry orca has wandered into the lagoon after escaping from a cheap SeaWorld knockoff. Named Cito, the whale was the main attraction at a theme park called World of Orca. That is until mistreatment and one specific tragic event drove Cito to kill a couple of her handlers. Now she’s trapped in the lagoon with those same killer instincts and three hapless humans as her prey. And so sets the table for another man vs beast showdown.
To Brechin’s credit, she attempts to make her film more than a copy-and-paste horror thriller. For a while she leans into the survival element, especially when the friends end up stranded on a small rock surrounded by water that’s being patrolled by a bloodthirsty orca. She also makes time for drama, giving the emotionally wounded Maddie the space to deal with her grief and potentially find closure. Unfortunately the drama is undermined by an ill-advised late twist that I’m sure sounded better on paper that it appeared on-screen.

As for any thrills, Brechin manages to generate some tension and suspense although not enough to put us on the edges of our seats. Her problem lies with the comically cheap digital effects that too often yanks us out of key scenes. The noticeable CGI isn’t just restricted to the massive killer whale, but to scenes where characters look superimposed onto their backgrounds. The artists do what they can, but they simply don’t have the funds to sell us on what we see.
We also encounter parts of the story that feel remarkably shortchanged. None more than the drama at World of Orca which is woefully underdeveloped despite having a rather significant impact on the story. Again, Brechin deserves credit for trying to make a movie that isn’t more of the same. She also smartly makes the human element central to her storytelling. But budget limitations and a few too many shortcuts keep this well-intentioned feature from delivering on its ambition.
VERDICT – 2 STARS



















