Céline Song burst onto the scene with her beautifully bittersweet romantic drama “Past Lives”. Her film released to near universal acclaim and would go on to earn Academy Award nominations for Best Picture and Best Original Screenplay. It deserved every bit of the praise. “Past Lives” was a sophisticated and heartfelt feature that brought a talented new filmmaker onto the scene.

Song follows her 2023 gem with “Materialists”, yet another romantic drama but without the lasting grip of her first film. This time she’s working with bigger names in Dakota Johnson, Chris Evans, and Pedro Pascal. But there’s no Greta Lee caliber standout performance. Johnson is a solid lead in a very Johnson-like role. Evans tones things down a few notches to deliver a fairly standard-issue character. And Pascal is fittingly suave but surprisingly dry with the exception of one lone scene where he delivers dialogue that doesn’t feel right off the page.

Following a brief and unintentionally hokey prologue, “Materialists” kicks off by taking us into the unusual world of high-end big city matchmaking. It’s where we meet Lucy (Johnson), a professional Cupid who works for Adore Matchmaking in downtown Manhattan. Her job is to offer services to struggling singles who are having a hard time finding the love of their lives. In her profession people are measured with sabermetrics. Matches are little more than equations. And if two people check enough boxes, Lucy puts them together with their eventual marriage as her trophy.

Lucy likes her job and by their own peculiar standards she seems to be good at it (we see Lucy and her fellow matchmakers celebrate her 9th client marriage). As far as her personal life, Lucy has remained voluntarily single while setting her own extremely high standards for any man she’ll date. “The next person I date I’m gonna marry,” she says without a moment’s hesitation.

But those standards are challenged when she attends her most recent client’s wedding. It’s there that she meets one of the groomsmen, Harry (Pascal). He’s handsome, confident, gentlemanly, and extremely wealthy. By her company’s stat-driven scale he’s a textbook perfect 10. But as the two are getting acquainted, Lucy is surprised to see John (Evans), an old flame working as a waiter at the wedding reception.

Immediately the table is set for yet another movie love triangle. But thankfully Song isn’t interested in taking us down that well-worn route. Her story explores relationships and the modern big city dating scene. But there’s no macho rivalry with Lucy caught in the middle. Even more, neither Harry or John are bad guys. Instead they represent two very different kinds of relationships. You could say there is a blue-collar versus white-collar dimension to the story. But neither are demonized or unfairly portrayed.

While the movie’s views on dating, love, and especially marriage are all over the map, it makes for an intriguing study of modern perspectives. Interestingly it’s the romantic relationships themselves that are the weakest parts of the story. Lucy’s connection with John feels the most authentic yet it’s also the most derivative. Meanwhile her connection with Harry only occasionally goes deeper than surface level. Far more compelling is a side story involving a client named Sophie (Zoë Winters) and the impact it ultimately has on Lucy.

“Materialists” may disappoint those hoping for another “Past Lives” level feature. It lacks the emotional richness, sincere longing, and heartfelt candor of Song’s magical debut. Yet she remains a thoughtful and keenly observant filmmaker who again brings together insight and craftsmanship. Sadly not everything gels as intended. Feelings are often explained rather than shown. Love is treated more as a concept than something expressed. And the film’s cynicism and earnestness often feels at odds with its more romantic swings. Still it’s all easy to soak in – a testament to what makes Song such a compelling filmmaker. “Materialists” is in theaters now.

VERDICT – 3 STARS