
From film critic to filmmaker, Chris Stuckmann moves from his YouTube screen to the directing chair with his debut feature “Shelby Oaks”. This unique supernatural horror mystery makes for an impressive feature film debut for Stuckmann who serves as director, writer, and producer. Even with a small budget, Stuckmann’s film almost didn’t get made due to a lack of funds. But that changed after a wildly successful Kickstarter campaign and NEON acquiring the distribution rights.
To his credit, Stuckmann doesn’t let budget constraints hinder his vision. As a result, “Shelby Oaks” is able to create the precise effect he’s going for. It’s a movie where atmosphere is the prime focus. And while he throws in a well-timed jump scare or two, Stuckmann concentrates most on creating and developing a steady sense of unease. It results in a richly atmospheric chiller that’s brimming with the kind of sustained tension that keeps you fidgeting in your seat for all the right reasons.
With “Shelby Oaks”, Stuckman employs several methods to tell his story. Much of the first half features a combination of documentary style and found footage. For many of us, the latter has ran its cinematic course. But Stuckmann uses found footage in a compelling way. And he wisely pulls away from it before it becomes a liability. The film’s second half goes the traditional narrative feature route which works well with the story he’s telling, despite some final act bumps in the road.
The story is an interesting mix of true crime and the supernatural. Without question it’s a creepy tone-centered horror film but with a distinct mystery element to it. The mystery revolves around the disappearance of Riley Brennen (Sarah Durn), the host of the YouTube ghost-hunting show “Paranormal Paranoids”. In 2008, Riley and her three crew members disappeared without a trace while investigating the old ghost town of Shelby Oaks.

Many believed the disappearances to be a hoax – a gimmick to build anticipation for their next episode. But when the three gruesomely murdered bodies of her crew members were discovered, the fate of Riley Brennen became a national discussion. The last time she was seen alive is in some grainy video footage that shows her leaving a room and being confronted by something outside of our sight.
Twelve years later, Riley’s sister Mia (Camille Sullivan) hasn’t given up her search. While being interviewed for an upcoming true crime documentary, Mia is visited by a mysterious man who rambles incorrectly before pulling out a gun and shooting himself in the head. A shocked Mia notices the man is clutching an old camcorder cassette labeled “Shelby Oaks” which she grabs before the police arrive. On it, Mia finds new information that refuels her already obsessive investigation.
In the first of several head-scratching character choices, Mia sets out for Shelby Oaks alone(?) and in the middle of the night(?) to follow her new leads. The series of dark discoveries she makes sends the story into some unsettling territory. And as the mystery patiently unfolds, the film is able to generate some authentic suspense, aided by the eerie and dread-drenched presentation from Stuckmann and his DP Andrew Scott Baird.
But as we’ve seen time and time again, landing the perfect ending isn’t as easy as it looks on paper. “Shelby Oaks” doesn’t botch its finish, but it leaves it feeling underdeveloped. The supernatural components are especially underwritten which shortchanges key pieces of the final 30 minutes. But the movie easily makes up for it in other areas, namely in creating a dark, immersive experience that embraces its classic horror inspirations while adding some of its own touches.
VERDICT – 3.5 STARS


















