
Japanese auteur Kiyoshi Kurosawa has carved a cinematic path that couldn’t be more different than that of the other esteemed filmmaker who shares his last name (no relation). Kurosawa cut his teeth on J-horror but quickly expanded his catalog to include dramas, black comedies, science-fiction, crime thrillers, and even a period spy movie. But his latest film sees him venturing into the genre that made the legendary Akira Kurosawa a household name.
With “The Samurai and the Prisoner”, Kiyoshi Kurosawa makes his first foray into the classic jidaigeki genre. Yet from its opening moments, you would never guess this was his first samurai film. Through an elegant combination of technical precision and creative intuition, Kurasawa transports us back to feudal Japan in a way that fits right in with the samurai classics of the past. Yet his story almost plays like a deconstruction as Kurosawa takes a critical look at the samurai code entire dynasty’s were built upon.

“The Samurai and the Prisoner” is an aggressively faithful adaptation of Honobu Yonezawa’s 2021 novel of the same name. It’s a mostly confined period epic where the bulk of the drama happens within a besieged castle. And though unwieldy and plodding at times, Kurosawa’s script is an intricate and evocative melding of the old and the new, both in its storytelling and its craftsmanship. It’s a chamber drama murder mystery told in a classical style but through a shrewdly modern lens.
The story is set in 16th century Japan as warlord Nobunaga Oda advances west with the aim of ruling the entire country. One of his most trusted retainers, Murashige Araki (Masahiro Motoki) of Arioka Castle in Settsu, suddenly turns against Oda. His reasons are a mystery, but they slowly and clearly come to light through the film’s patient episodic structure. And as the battles with Oda’s forces intensify outside of Murashige’s impregnable fortress, a more cunning war is being waged within his walls that threatens to tear his castle apart from the inside out.
The screws begin to tighten with the arrival of Kanbei (Masaki Suda), a master strategist and Oda’s envoy. Kanbei warns Murashige of Oda’s gathering army and urges him to surrender. Instead of sending him back, Murashige has Kanbei locked in a dungeon, which is his first of several breaks from samurai tradition. A short time later, an unexplained murder inside the castle sparks rumors among the soldiers, prompting Murashige to seek help from an unlikely source – the imprisoned Kanbei.
Kurosawa unwraps much of his story through a number of dense dungeon discussions between the perplexed samurai lord and his crafty captive. What begins as Murashige’s firm establishment of power turns into gripping verbal chess matches between foes. But when Kanbei’s power of deduction leads Murashige towards solving the murder, the prisoner begins earning the trust of the castle’s embattled leader. And that trust grows as Murashige continues to consult Kanbei following a series of other mysteries that threaten his standing among his clans.

The whodunit mysteries themselves shrewdly feed the film’s central storyline. But it’s Murashige’s loyalty to his convictions that adds the most compelling layer. Take his refusal to have a young man crucified as punishment for his father’s shame. Or his choice to have a soldier exiled rather than executed for his betrayal. Murashige’s decisions routinely clash with the rigid and often merciless samurai code. And that challenges those under his command, who find themselves torn between faithfulness to their esteemed leader or to their long-held and deeply rooted customs. It’s a fascinating conflict with no easy resolution.
As the drama unfolds, Kurosawa remains far more intrigued with exploring the intellectual, psychological, existential, and philosophical facets of his story rather than indulge in sword duels and battlefield combat. It’s a focus that can sometimes leave the movie feeling staid, slow-moving, and emotionally distant. And while it’s a handsomely shot film, Kurosawa mostly shuns the idea of thrilling spectacle. Yet “The Samurai and the Prisoner” remains a captivating watch, despite its occasional sluggishness. Kurosawa earns our investment and grounds us in the drama, making this strikingly unique period epic hard to turn away from.
VERDICT – 4 STARS



















