“Sentimental Value” is the latest film from director Joachim Trier and his follow-up to 2022’s Oscar-nominated “The Worse Person in the World”. It sees him rejoining his regular writing partner Eskil Vogt to tell a resonant and layered story that uses the behind-the-scenes drama of a film shoot to explore the idea of reconciliation through art. It’s tricky ground to cover, but Trier succeeds thanks to his keen focus and tight grip on this mature and thoughtful material.

Trier also reteams with the extraordinary actress Renate Reinsve for their third collaboration. She plays a stage and television actress named Nora Borg. She and her younger sister Agnes (Inga Ibsdotter Lilleaas) have their world shaken when their estranged father Gustav (Stellan Skarsgård) re-enters their lives. Gustav left when the girls were still young and his reappearance brings back waves of painful feelings, especially for Nora.

Gustav has had a successful filmmaking career, but it has come at the expense of his relationships with his daughters. Yet despite his success, Gustav hasn’t released a feature film in fifteen years. But he has written a new script – one that is very close to his heart. And he uses it in as a means of reaching out to his daughters in the only way he competently knows how – through the very artistic language that pulled him away in the beginning.

In one of the film’s (and one of the year’s) very best scenes, Gustav invites Nora to a diner where they can finally have what he calls a “proper talk”. The father-daughter tension is immediate and it comes through in every word penned by Trier and Vogt. It also pours from the profoundly genuine performances of Reinsve and Skarsgård, who shrewdly convey the emotional complexities within their characters. The exchanges that follow are riveting.

Gustav tells Nora he has written what he thinks is the best script of his career. He presents her with a copy to read saying he wants her to play the lead. Galled by his nerve, a stunned Nora angrily rejects his offer. “I wrote it for you,” he declares as if expecting her to immediately reconsider. “You’re the only one who can play it.” As Nora storms out, we are naturally sympathetic to her side. But Trier doesn’t paint Gustav as a villain. Instead he leaves us with our own questions about the character. Is Gustav’s script just a tool to get back in his daughters’ good graces? Is he using Nora to get extra funding for his film? Or is there something deeper and more personal?

“Sentimental Value” is a movie about daddies and daughters. But it’s also a movie about sisters. Nora and Agnes have a thoughtfully drawn relationship that grew stronger with every family trial they endured together. Agnes seems to have the more stable life. She’s happily married and has an adorable young son. Nora’s prickly veneer hides a vulnerability that weighs on her soul. She struggles with anxiety and loneliness, trying to satisfy both with ill-advised choices that hurt more than help. But the sisters share a special connection that Trier observes through various lenses.

Another crucial character in the film happens to be the family’s ancestral home which houses several generations of memories and trauma. Gustav still owns the house – a fact his daughters learned after their mother died. Gustav was raised there, and the secrets within its walls inform why he’s reluctant to part with it. He’s still wrestling with those secrets which date back to his own childhood, and his new film is his way of reckoning with it.

The richly observed family dynamics only get more compelling with each dramatic turn. One of the biggest comes when Gustav decides to shoot his new film in the family’s house. Even more, he brings in Rachel Kemp (Elle Fanning), a popular American actress, to play the lead role that Nora turned down. It’s a compelling turn of events that allows Trier to take Nora and Gustav in revealing new directions which poignantly help to define their relationship.

“Sentimental Value” sees Joachim Trier cementing himself as one of the must-see filmmakers of our time. Some may argue he had already achieved that status. But his latest film is his best to date. In it we see Trier broadening his focus yet maintaining the intimacy that has made his other films so incisive and nuanced. His considerations of fractured relationships, past family trauma, and art as a means of healing have significant weight and are delivered with such an assured sense of purpose that we can’t help but be utterly captivated by the drama that unfolds on screen.

VERDICT – 4 STARS