
Michel Franco has never been one to shy away from challenging his audiences with provocative subject matter. He attempts it again with his latest film, “Dreams”, a strangely confounding psychodrama that seems to have several things it wants to say but no firm grasp on how to say them. It’s cold, sometimes aimless, and borderline absurd at times in its attempts to find a steady pulse.
“Dreams” sees Franco reuniting with his star, Jessica Chastain. The two first collaborated in 2023’s superior “Memory”, a deeply affecting adult drama that saw Chastain give one of her best performances to date. She’s certainly the highlight of “Dreams”, although neither her character or her character’s journey carry the same dramatic or emotional weight.

“Dreams” opens with a young Mexican dancer named Fernando (a somewhat dry Isaac Hernández) being smuggled into the United States in the back of a sweltering semi-trailer. After finally being released by cartel traffickers, Fernando makes the long, arduous journey from San Antonio to San Francisco where he surprises his older and wealthier former lover, Jennifer (Chastain). With practically no build-up whatsoever, the two instantly pick up where they (apparently) left off.
Jennifer’s feelings for Fernando remain murky for the duration of the movie. She is the daughter of a prominent philanthropist named Michael McCarthy (Marshall Bell) and helps run her father’s thriving foundation with her brother Jake (Rupert Friend). Her privileged and pampered life is in stark contrast to Fernando’s which sometimes seeps through when they’re together. At times she treats him like her pet, scratching him behind his ear and saying things like “I want to take care of you.”

Yet Jennifer is also obsessed with him in a way that goes beyond mere entitlement. This intensifies after Fernando grows tired of keeping their affair secret and leaves her. As he finds his independence she sinks into despair, eventually shadowing him with the voracity of a stalker. It ends up steering the movie away from its themes of immigration and class disparity and towards a story about power dynamics within an unconvincing couple.
Despite being handed a character who never feels fully formed, Chastain carries the movie on her back via a committed performance that elevates the material. But she can only do so much. The film’s Achilles’ heel is the central relationship which never comes off as authentic or rooted in anything other than unabated lust. And any swing at something weightier is muddled in the film’s jarring final twenty minutes that pulls a wild twist out of the air. It’s meant to shock us. But it’s too contrived and abrupt to have the impact Franco clearly wants. Kinda like his movie as a whole.
VERDICT – 2 STARS


















