REVIEW: “Nebraska”

NEB POSTER

In the comedy/drama “Nebraska” Bruce Dern plays an elderly man named Woody Grant from Billings, Montana. Woody receives a marketing flyer in the mail that convinces him he has won $1 million. All he needs to do to collect is travel to Lincoln, Nebraska and claim his prize. The problem is his two sons and his cantankerous wife all know it’s a scam. But Woody is determined that he is going to Lincoln even if he has to go on foot. To appease Woody, David (Will Forte) agrees to drive him to Lincoln and hopefully have some bonding time with the father he barely knew.

That’s the main story, but this is an Alexander Payne film so you know there is a lot more under the surface. Payne has always been interested in characters and this is a character-driven picture. “Nebraska” touches on a variety of real life subjects including alcoholism, greed, family dysfunction, and declining health of the elderly among others. And while there’s nothing inherently funny about these things, Payne and writer Bob Nelson don’t allow the movie to drown in its seriousness. In fact at times it’s a very funny film – that near perfect mix of comedy and drama.

NEB1

One of my favorite things about “Nebraska” is its authenticity. This could easily have been a conventional comedy featuring a stereotypical old codger. Instead it’s a very real story featuring real characters and set around a very real depiction of small-town America. With a few small exceptions, “Nebraska” never hits a false note. The majority of the time the characters feel just right and the Nebraska locations seem yanked out of real life.

I also love the choice to shoot the film in black-and-white. While it wasn’t popular with the studio, Payne and cinematographer Phedon Papamichael saw it as an intricate part of their storytelling. I think it was a brilliant choice. It creates a very gloomy and bleak look that is perfectly in tune with much of Woody’s story. But it also works in the film’s portrayal of America’s dying small towns. There is a striking parallel between Woody and these rural locales that I found fascinating and the black-and-white made it all the more powerful. But at the same time there is a beauty to the look of this picture – a classic beauty that I don’t think color could provide.

That hints at another facet of the movie that really worked me. As someone born and raised in a place very similar to Woody’s hometown of Hawthorne, I was impressed with the film’s accuracy in capturing the essence of the small town. Payne, a Nebraska native, was able to show the sad side of what these places look like now while also painting a beautiful picture of how they once were.

NEB3

But once again it’s the characters that gives this film its life. Bruce Dern delivers one of the most earnest and committed performances of the year. Woody is a captivating character with more layers than you may think. He’s deeply flawed yet genuinely sympathetic. He can be unintentionally hilarious yet also sad and depressing. There is also a cloud of mystery that surrounds Woody. We get hints that he’s battling some form of dementia but it’s never clearly stated. Also, through the eyes of his wife and sons, we see Woody as a pretty bad husband, father, and man. Yet we learn new things about him from the people in his hometown that tell a slightly different story. There are numerous other nuances to this character that I loved.

The great film critic Leonard Maltin noted that “Payne has a Fellini-like eye for great faces”. I couldn’t have said it better. Much like a Coen brothers film, there are an assortment of memorable faces which add so much character and detail to the setting and the story itself. Everywhere you look there is one small character that feels a part of the fabric that makes up “Nebraska”.

NEB2

There are also an assortment of other great characters many of which are comic spark plugs. Perhaps the most talked about is June Squibb as Woody’s mean and degrading wife Kate. She undoubtedly has some of the movie’s funniest moments, but she also exposes one of the film’s only problems. Payne takes her snarky, belligerent, and sometimes foul attitude a bit too far. Don’t get me wrong, I laughed my butt off at some of her antics, but Payne overdoes it. Here’s an example. There’s a great scene where Kate, Woody, and David are visiting family grave sites at a small country cemetery. It’s a fantastic scene with the right mix of drama and humor. That is until the Kate character suddenly does a vulgar act clearly intended for a cheap laugh. It really hurts what could have been a brilliant scene.

While Payne does overplay his hand which hurts the movie a bit, I still found “Nebraska” to be one of the strongest films of the year. Not only is it a piercing examination of some very real issues, it’s also one of the funniest movies of 2013. And if Bruce Dern doesn’t get a Best Actor Oscar nomination for his phenomenal work, it will be hard to take the category seriously. I really like “Nebraska” and I think it’s a better film than Payne’s beloved “The Descendants”. It is smart and fresh filmmaking that I really hope gets rewarded this awards season.

VERDICT – 4.5 STARS

Advertisements

23 thoughts on “REVIEW: “Nebraska”

    • Thanks! It’s extremely well done. Payne gets a little carried away in parts which is the only thing negative I can say about it. It’s poignant but also laugh out loud funny at times!

  1. Good review Keith. It’s a small, slow and subdued movie, but that’s exactly the type Payne excels in and this one is no different. Just not as good, really.

    • Interesting take. It’s definitely smaller and more subdued. But I really think it’s one of his better pictures. I particularly liked it better than the more poplar “The Descendants”.

      Thanks for reading and for the comments.

  2. WOW Keith! I was about to post this exact same review, and guess what, we have the same rating! I was pleasantly surprised how much I enjoyed this one, I sure hope Dern is going to be nominated for Oscar. I like The Descendants but I actually like this one a tad more

    • That is very cool! Haven’t had many hits on my review but I’m hoping to spread the word on this film. Really have a strong appreciation for this movie and Dern’s performance. It’s funny – this review of a movie I loved followed yesterday’s review of a movie I despised! Good to get back on track although I have another stinker I’m writing now.

      What are your thoughts on my take on the Kate character?

      • Yeah I feel that her remarks are pretty outrageous, but I don’t know if Payne went too far necessarily as she’s not in the film very much. I think overall her character is constantly saying nutty things, w/ the cemetery one being the worst! In any case, this film is more hilarious than I though, the scene at the barn w/ the whole Grant family is a hoot!

      • Oh I loved the barn scene. Hysterical. As for Kate, i think she had some of the movie’s funniest moments. Just a tad to loud and obvious in a handful of scenes. But her performance was fantastic. She was so genuine. I don’t recall seeing in before but she was really good here.

  3. Nice review. I an early screening of Nebraska and it’s one of my favorites of the year. Like you said, it mixes drama and comedy very well and I’m hoping Bruce Dern gets nominated at the Oscars.

    • Wasn’t Dern great? I really laughed a lot in this film but it’s also a pretty moving film at times. Like you mentioned, a great mix.

      Oh, by the way, a huge THANKS to you for being one of my top 5 commenters from 2013. I can’t tell you how much I appreciate that.

  4. Pingback: The Top 10 Films of 2013 |

  5. Finally caught up with this film. Your comments seem pretty insightful. I’m not sure I agree that the act Kate performers at the cemetery is as unrealistic as you suggest. She appears to have been willing to hit for extra bases when young and seniors often lose some inhibitions. Dern is great in a quiet way. He seems to have fewer lines than anyone else but holds the screen and conveys some ideas with that great face. I liked how unsentimental the film is. Even the ending manages a good moment without overdoing the schmaltz.

    • Glad you had a chance to see it. I’m a big fan of the film (as its place on my Top 10 proves). I found it to be simply beautiful filmmaking. Lots of heart and some really good humor.

  6. Pingback: 2013 K&M Random Movie Awards |

  7. Pingback: Nebraska | The Soul of the Plot

  8. Pingback: Top 5 Performances of 2013 – Lead Actor |

  9. Pingback: » Movie Review – Toy Story 2 Fernby Films

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s