REVIEW: “Mildred Pierce” (1945)

Classic Movie SpotlightMildred PierceJoan Crawford had an interesting career to say the least. In 1937 she was called “The Queen of the Movies” by Life magazine but she would be called “Box Office Poison” only one year later. A few moderate successes would follow before her 18 year run with MGM studios was ended. Hungry for a new start, Crawford signed with Warner Brothers. One of her first pictures with her new studio was “Mildred Pierce”. The film was a huge success and Crawford would go on to win the Best Actress Oscar. Her performance was rightly recognized and her career was revived.

“Mildred Pierce” was directed by Michael Curtiz. The acclaimed director didn’t want Crawford as his lead but after his first choices bowed out (Bette Davis, Barabara Stanwyck, Olivia de Havilland), she got the job. The film was adapted from James Cain’s edgy 1941 hardboiled novel. Several plot lines from the book couldn’t be included in the picture due to the movie content code restrictions of the time. This allowed for the film’s introduction of the murder angle and several other creative differences.

Speaking of that, the movie opens with a murder. In a wonderful opening scene dripping with noir flavor, a man is shot several times by an unseen assailant who then flees the scene. The police bring in a successful restauranteur named Mildred Pierce (Crawford) for questioning. The murder victim turns out to be Mildred’s second husband Monte Beragon (Zachary Scott) and the cops believe they know who did it. The main plot structure is built around her interrogation. Through flashbacks we are introduced to the main players and we follow Mildred’s rise from a hard working single mother to an owner of multiple restaurants in the Southern California area.

But we are also introduced to a darker side of Mildred’s life. It’s a side featuring two failed marriages, an unthinkable tragedy, and a bitter, contentious relationship with her oldest daughter Veda. It’s Veda who may be Mildred’s biggest failing. We watch her become a selfish and materialistic young girl who is actually a product of Mildred’s own making. Her desire to shower upon her daughter the most lavish things creates a scheming young girl who looks down with great haughtiness on the ‘have-nots’. Ann Blyth plays Veda and she is sublime. Blyth was actually on loan from Universal Studios at the time. Her performance garnered well-deserved praise which culminated in a Best Supporting Actress Oscar nomination. Blyth would make several more films but none as memorable as “Mildred Pierce”. She was only 17 at the time but this performance showed an astuteness and attention usually associated with the greats.

Mildred Pierce1

There is an assortment of other great side characters that help tell Mildred’s story. Bruce Bennett plays her first husband Bert who subverts any good intentions he may have with his carousing and disrespect. Yet you end up wondering if he knows more about Mildred than we first do. Then there is Bert’s real estate partner Wally (Jack Carson) who is never beyond an occasional flirt or a shady business deal. He’s a rather slimy fellow who also has self-centered intentions. Eve Arden gets some wonderful lines as Mildred’s friend and restaurant manager. And Butterfly McQueen has some good moments as Mildred’s maid.

While the film revolves around the murder of Beragon, the life of Mildred Pierce is the centerpiece. Much of the movie’s brilliance is shown in its storytelling style and in the clever ways it depicts Mildred’s changes. She’s an entirely different person by the film’s end. She becomes a woman enslaved by the poisonous relationship she has with her daughter. Things become darker and more twisted as the film moves along which gives “Mildred Pierce” a unique sense. It slices up and mixes portions of film noir, mystery, and romance to form a sordid yet thoroughly compelling whole.

I’m a big fan of “Mildred Pierce” and it’s easily one of my favorite Joan Crawford pictures. She is exceptional here as is her supporting cast, particularly young Ann Blyth. Ranald MacDougall’s adaptation is smart and crafty and it works seamlessly with Michael Curtiz’s style of direction. The film takes a few unavoidable diversions from the novel but they nicely translate cinematically. It all resulted in a spirited film that showcased a still relevant Crawford. It’s also a true classic that still packs a hefty punch today.


25 thoughts on “REVIEW: “Mildred Pierce” (1945)

    • Thanks man. Give it a watch. I’m a huge classic film fan and love promoting these great flicks. I don’t know how good I promote them though. The Classic Movie Spotlights always have the least amount of comments! LOL

  1. Great review of sound like an interesting film.

    I have never seen a Joan Crawford film, to the best of my memory, and I’m not sure I’ll be able to. Whether or not Mommie Dearest is accurate as to Crawford’s parenting, it poisoned me against the woman.

    • LOL. Crawford was certainly wicked in that portrayal, wasn’t she? That’s one of those things where we don’t know what to believe. One of her two disinherited children writes “Mommie Dearest” while her two other children denounce it.

      As for this film I hope you will give it a look. This won’t change Crawford’s motherly image, but she gives an excellent performance and the film is very well made.

      I appreciate you reading and commenting! I don’t get a lot of feedback whenever I spend time on classic films. But I can’t help it, I adore these films.

  2. Wow I never saw anything by Joan Crawford, crazy eh? So is this the same Mildred Pierce character as the TV movie that Kate Winslet did? Pardon my ignorance on the topic Keith [sheepish smile]

    • Yep! Both are adaptations from James Cain’s novel. I haven’t seen all of Winslet’s mini-series but they appear to be quite different. Crawford is very good but Ann Blyth is amazing in this film! Hope you get a chance to see it.

      • Oh I know who Ann Blyth is as she was one of Greg Peck’s co-stars 😉 I’d recommend The World in His Arms if you like her Keith, I can lend it to you if you want to borrow it!

  3. Great review. Not only is this one of my favourite Joan Crawford movies it rivals Now Voyager as one of my favourite 1940’s melodramas.
    Great characters, gorgeous to look at and Eve Arden! In light and shadows, Mildred Pierce is a perfect Sunday afternoon movie.

    • Fantastic to hear from someone else who really appreciates this film. It’s wonderful filmmaking and it features some great performances. Isn’t Eve Arden fantastic?

      Thanks for the comments.

  4. I loved this movie, when I watched it a couple of years ago. It’s pure Excellence!! I think it deserves a 5 star rating, I gave it a 10 on IMDB. Both Crawford and Blythe are superb as is Curtiz’s direction. Am glad other stars bowed out and Crawford got the chance. Nice review Keith.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s