Regardless of whether you were a fan or not, if you were alive in the late 1980s and early 1990s you probably heard of Milli Vanilli. The German duo of Rob Pilatus and Fab Morvan became overnight pop music sensations. They would go on to sell millions of records, release three #1 singles, and win a Grammy Award for Best New Artist. But scandal erupted once it was discovered that Rob and Fab didn’t actually sing their songs. As a result, Milli Vanilli received instant backlash and they would eventually have their Grammy taken away.

Rob and Fab would make several attempts to save their careers but to no avail. In 1998 the duo recorded a return album and were planning a full promotional tour. But tragedy struck, putting an end to any potential comeback. Without question they have a heartbreaking ‘rise-and-fall’ story which has been chronicled in several documentaries. Director Bret Ratner had a Milli Vanilli biopic in the works, but it fell apart after sexual harassment allegations against him became public.

And that leads to “Girl You Know It’s True”, a new biographical drama written, directed, and co-produced by Simon Verhoeven. The film makes an effort to rescue the sullied reputations of Rob Pilatus and Fabrice Morvan. Yet it does so without exonerating them of their roles in the elaborate ruse. Verhoeven sets out to humanize Milli Vanilli by looking beyond their celebrity status. He offers a sympathetic cautionary tale told through an illuminating and stylish lens.

In 1988 Rob Pilatus (Tijan Njie) met Fabrice Morvan (Elan Ben Ali) on the Munich, Germany club scene. The two dancers had a lot in common including their love for music and their dreams of becoming big stars. After some low-paying, go-nowhere jobs as background dancers and catalog models, Rob and Fab realize they need to get noticed. So they put aside working on songs to work on their image. They design their own unique look – the signature long braids, torn jeans, frilly jackets. And it works. They get noticed by Milli (Bella Dayne), the assistant to successful record producer Frank Farian (Matthias Schweighöfer).

Frank had struck it big in 1976 with the German disco band Boney M. Now he’s working on a new project. He has a song, “Girl You Know It’s True”, and two great singers, John Davis (Samuel S. Franklin) and Brad Howell (David Mayonga). But they weren’t “MTV material”. So Frank sits down with Rob and Fab and tells them, “I’m looking for stars.” The young, naive, and vulnerable duo sign a contract without fully understanding the terms. They believe they’ll get to sing the track. In reality, they’re hired to be good-looking, lip-syncing frontmen for a group Frank calls Milli Vanilla.

From there, Verhoeven details the duo’s meteoric rise from a popular local act in Germany to being the biggest pop stars on the planet. He includes Milli Vanilli’s signing with Arista records, their subsequent move to Los Angeles, the 1989 Club MTV disaster, the 1990 Grammy night performance, the ruthless legal battle over a potential world tour, and the public revelation that brought their entire world crashing down on top of them.

Through all of that, the movie never shortchanges the human side of Rob and Fab. They add to their own troubles after being swayed by the allure of fame. Drugs, alcohol, and women all play their parts. But we also see them manipulated by people they trust, most notably greedy executives who swoop in like vultures to cash in on their successes. Opportunity is dangled in front of them like a carrot on a string by devious and powerful opportunists. Yet through it all Rob and Fab kept believing they could turn the illusion into reality. They kept believing they would one day get their chance to sing.

In one of the film’s stranger choices, the story is partially narrated by Rob and Fab (and briefly by Frank) who appear intermittently, breaking the fourth wall to share their perspectives before ushering us into another key moment on their timeline. It’s a peculiar yet moderately effective approach that offers more human layers and a surprising amount of insight. But (as with most of the movie) it’s the superb performances from Njie and Ali that makes it all click.

In showing Milli Vanilli’s crushing fall from pop superstardom, Verhoeven doesn’t let anyone off the hook. Rob and Fab’s gullibility and love of the limelight certainly played a part. But the film is just as much an indictment of an industry so obsessed with record sales that the art and artists are often afterthoughts. And it also points out the culpability of the consumers, who devour acts who look the part and tickle our senses. As Rob states in one solemn moment of truth, “We gave you what you wanted.” That kind of candor, mixed with unexpected helpings of heart and humor, helps elevate this into something more than another run-of-the-mill biopic. “Girl You Know It’s True” opens August 9th in select theaters and on VOD.

VERDICT – 3.5 STARS