In the 2000 romantic drama “Chocolat” a woman comes into a small French village and attempts to inject new life into the prudish community through her scrumptious chocolates. Sounds a little odd, right? Well in some ways it is but the film also delves into several heavier social and family issues sometimes convincingly but not always. It does have plenty of entertaining moments and it features some fine performances, but I’m still not convinced it’s a film worthy of the Oscar Best Picture nomination it received.
The story is based on Joanne Harris’ novel and written for the screen by Robert Nelson Jacobs. It takes place the a fictional French hilltop village of Lansquenet-sous-Tannes. One day a strong north wind blows Vianne (Juliette Binoche) and her young daughter Anouk (Victoire Thivisol) into town. The two newcomers quickly rent an abandoned patisserie and the apartment above it from the crabby Armande (Judi Dench). Vianne turns the place into a chocolate shop and begins to capture the attention of the locals.
One such local is Comte Paul de Reynaud (Alfred Molina), the town’s mayor who rules the community with an iron moral fist. He’s particularly turned off by Vianne for her more provocative attire and her insistence on opening a chocolate shop at the start of Lent. Reynaud goes to great lengths to sour the people’s view of Vianne but as more people taste her magical chocolate concoctions a profound change begins to take place in the village. Several townsfolk find that her chocolates cure personal troubles in their lives. They spark a new romance, they lead someone to independence, and in another case they even work as supercharged Viagra.
It seems that organized religion may serve as the punching bag in this film. It’s portrayed as stuffy, intolerant, and overbearing. But it’s the concept that’s the target more than the people. The people are treated more as simple-minded followers with Reynaud being the moral dictator and true mouthpiece of the church. But I was never fully convinced that Vianne was such a great person either. She certainly exposes several of the churches hypocrisies and she makes the lives of several people better. But she also uses some pretty disrespectful tactics including usurping parental authority and planning a fertility celebration on Easter Sunday clearly to be confrontational. The film treats these moves as positive but that’s not the way to win me over to her perspective. And what exactly is she? Is she a witch, a chocolate magician? I never did figure it out.
The film’s strongest point is its acting. Binoche is brilliant and she has always amazed me with the believability she brings to ever performance. Judi Dench was also great as Vianne’s grumpy landlady. Dench does ‘surly’ well and she’s a real treat here. I also loved the always underrated Alfred Molina. He was fantastic as a character who’s a lot more complex than you may think. Johnny Depp even pops up in a smaller role as a river drifter who catches Vianne’s eye. There are several other fine performances worth mentioning from Lena Olin, Carrie-Anne Moss, Leslie Caron, and Peter Stormare.
“Chocolat” is a movie that’s entertaining despite its occasional heavy-handedness and familiar storylines. It does suffer from a few periods of dullness and the conventional ending seems a little disjointed considering how most of the film seems quite unconventional. But it’s the performances that carry this film and there are enough interesting developments in the story to keep things moving. Yet despite that, there were some things that kept pushing me away and I can’t help thinking that there was potential here for a little more satisfying experience.
Nice review mate. Not really my kind of thing if I’m honest, but I might check it out if I come across it at some point.
It’s a nice little film that was a surprise hit when it came out. The Academy sure loved it – a bit more than me for sure.
Nice review Keith. It’s a good movie that the Academy loved to death for some odd reason. However, the only reason I barely even remember this movie nowadays is because of I Love You, Man. “It’s pronounced Chocolat!” “No, it’s chocolate!”
The Academy drooled all over this one. Now it’s not a bad movie at all but it’s not an Oscar contender in my book.
Magic realism. The movie is all about charm rather than logic. The conflict between religion and happiness is a typical theme but was relatively harmless here. The diversity of stories brought together by the chocolate store is mostly a chance for us to think about how our lives are dominated by issues that we can have control over if we give ourselves the chance.
It didnt have that profound of an impact on me unfortunately. Instead I was thinking of how all of the side stories were run-of-the-mill and you knew exactly how all were going to play out. I didn’t find it as contemplative as it seems to want to be. But yet there’s enjoyment to be found.
I really enjoyed this one! I actually saw it my girlfriends on a movie nite but I don’t mind seeing it again on my own. I like Depp & Binoche but I was also impressed by Molina and Judi Dench in this, both of them had memorable roles!
Isn’t Molina good? I really think he’s a solid actor. I loved him here.
Mmmmm, not sure this is my type of film. Maybe that’s why I’ve passed on it for 13 years! :p
LOL! You may be right my friend!
This doesn’t sound like one I’d be interested in (I think I’d have the same problems as you do), but I’m impressed by the cast. Lot of talented actors there. And I agree that Molina is underrated — even in some lousy films I’ve seen him in, he’s always fun to watch.
I did think it was pretty good but I’m in no rush to see it again. I’m really surprised it got so much Oscar hype. Glad you agree about Molina. I think he’s always fun.