
And here we are again. Another year gone and another batch of fresh Oscar nominations to talk about, stew on, and grumble over. As is always the case the Academy gave us a handful of surprises, far more frustrations, and several choices that still boggle the mind. As I’m prone to do, here are a few random thoughts about this year’s head-scratching Academy Award nominations.
- Let me get this out of the way. “Vice”? Really? Eight nominations for Adam McKay’s messy, bloated, and utterly boring political manifesto disguised as a biopic? Is this a case of Hollywood voting politics over quality? It’s a legitimate question.
- For some weird reason only eight movies make up the Best Picture field, and of those eight only one made my Top 20 (“Roma”). They really had to room for “First Man”or “If Beale Street Could Talk”? More on those later.
- Thankfully the ludicrous Best Popular Film category was shelved but it looks like the Academy made up for it. “Black Panther”, “Bohemian Rhapsody”, and “A Star is Born” all get Best Picture nods.
- In the category of Best Song you have the sure-fire winner “Shallow” from “A Star is Born”. But I screamed with joy when I heard “When a Cowboy Trades His Spurs for Wings”. Of course it won’t win, but it’s one of 2018’s best musical moments.
- Sadly nothing for “Mission:Impossible – Fallout”. But who thought there would be?
- For the rest of my days I’ll always think of one thing come Oscar nomination time – Dick Poop. What can I say? My wife tells me I’m easily amused. Not sure what I’m talking about? Go to YouTube and type ‘Dick Poop Academy’. now back to the nominees…
- What to make of the messy Best Director lot? Bradley Cooper is being considered the biggest snub. Pawel Pawlikowski was the one no one saw coming. But its the crappy additions of McKay (“Vice”) and Lanthimos (“The Favourite”) who clog up the category.
- Once again the Academy shows no love for female directors. Only five women have ever been nominated in the category. This year Debra Granik and Lynne Ramsay would have been great additions but when you cram in the likes of McKay…
- And once again no room for Barry Jenkins (“If Beale Street Could Talk”) or Damien Chazelle (“First Man”) for Best Director? But when you cram in the likes of McKay…
- Spike Lee’s nomination for “BlacKkKlansman” was actually his first EVER for directing.
- The Academy fell hard for “The Favourite” handing it 10 nominations. I still don’t see the appeal. I found it to be shallow, humorless and pointlessly dark-hearted. But what do I know?
- Sam Rockwell gets a Supporting Actor nomination for “Vice”? Look I love Rockwell, but he looked like he was doing a SNL skit. I might be onboard if the award was for Best Imitation. Bad choice Academy.
- Marina de Tavira gets a Supporting Actress nod at the expense of a much more deserving Claire Foy (“First Man”). This glaring omission makes no sense whatsoever.
- Speaking of “First Man”, it was all but forgotten by the Academy voters this year. What a shame. Nothing for Best Picture, nothing for Chazelle, nothing for Foy. It was even shut out of a category is was thought to have a chance to win – Best Score. But at least “Vice” got eight nominations.
- Love the Adam Driver nomination for Supporting Actor. It wasn’t necessarily a surprise but as this year proves you never know.
- I read where the Academy has a history of snubbing documentaries that actually do well at the box office. That was certainly the case for the fabulous “Won’t You Be My Neighbor”. Not even a nomination? Give me a break.
- Oh, and nothing for “Three Identical Strangers”. Hmmm.
- Best Actor…sigh. To be honest there are some really strong performances in this category. But in my lone personal opinion I see the category as incomplete without Ethan Hawke for “First Reformed”. It’s career best work and deserving of the statue, not just the nomination.
- And speaking of Best Actor, wouldn’t it have been great to see John David Washington (“BlacKkKlansman”) and Joaquin Phoenix (“You Were Never Really There”) get some nomination love?
- Again, the Academy couldn’t find room for “If Beale Street Could Talk” in the Best Picture field? In fact, they barely found room for it anywhere. Sad. It’s a better film than his Oscar-adorned “Moonlight”.
- My Oscar enthusiasm dropped even more when Emily Blunt wasn’t nominated for either “A Quiet Place” or “Mary Poppins Returns”. Let us all join hands and shed a collective tear in unison.
- No Timothee Chalamet for Supporting Actor? I’ll admit, I’m surprised. There’s a good chance the weird Rockwell nomination took his spot.
- Oh, and no Michael B. Jordan for “Black Panther”. Wasn’t there a time when he was a lock? Maybe that February release removed Jordan from some voters’ memories. Again, a better choice than Rockwell.
- Some are looking at “Crazy Rich Asians” as a big snub. While I like that film, it’s hardly Oscar-worthy stuff. Here we get a rare bit of reality from the Academy.
- While both “Green Book” and “Bohemian Rhapsody” received nominations (much to the chagrin of social media), does anyone else get the feeling that their run is pretty much done? Malek is a possible Best Actor contender, but otherwise you get the sense that both films may have run out of gas.
- An actual year with no token Meryl Streep nomination? Woo Hoo!
- We actually have some drama in a couple of categories. Best Actress could be the most interesting with Lady Gaga, Olivia Colman, and Glenn Close all in the running.
- Has “Roma” positioned itself as the Best Picture front-runner? I would like to think so but don’t be so sure. It’s also in the Best Foreign Language category which could be problematic for its Best Picture chances. Being in both categories could easily split votes allowing another film to sneak in and take the biggest prize of the night.
- Netflix has to be smiling. With a big showing for “Roma” and a couple of surprising (and welcomed) nominations for “Buster Scruggs”, the streaming giant has finally broken through. Should have happened with “Mudbound”.
- The Best Original Screenplay group makes my head hurt. The writing is one of the worst things about “Vice”. It’s far from a strength in “The Favourite”. “Green Book” was fine but Oscar-worthy? At least Paul Schrader made the cut.
- Adapted Screenplay is far more interesting. “Beale Street”, “Buster Scruggs”, “BlacKkKlansman”, all worthy competitors.
- “Never Look Away” gets a nomination for “Best Cinematography”. I’ve never seen it so I can’t speak to its credibility. But I don’t remember anyone having it among their predictions.
- “Black Panther” ended up with seven nominations, something that was all but channeled back in February. It was destined for a Best Picture nomination and is the first Marvel movie to get one. But is it really one of the year’s best movies?
- There were so many great performances from young actors and actresses but all were shunned by the Academy. Elsie Fisher had the best shot but both she and “Eighth Grade” ended up with zilch.
- I haven’t seen “Burning” but had heard nothing but praise. Not seeing it’s name among the Best Foreign Language films was quite a surprise.
So those are a few random thoughts (perhaps better worded as ‘random gripes’). What did you think of this morning’s announcements?




















